A Fierce Advocate For

Clients’ Rights

Fines for a first-time shoplifting conviction can be very high

On Behalf of | Dec 21, 2023 | Criminal Defense |

Shoplifting can have serious outcomes, especially for people facing these charges for the first time in New Jersey. The fines for first-time offenses may far exceed the actual value of the stolen merchandise.

This can leave individuals with a financial burden disproportionate to their crime.

The cost of a first-time shoplifting conviction

New Jersey imposes fines that range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on the value of the stolen goods. More than that, stealing an item worth $200 or more elevates the offense to a felony.

In some instances, the fines can be multiples of the merchandise’s original worth. This can leave offenders confused.

Disproportionate punishment

One of the key issues arising from the enforcement of shoplifting fines in New Jersey is the apparent disproportionality between the value of stolen items and the financial penalties. For minor infractions involving low-value merchandise, the fines may exceed the actual worth of the stolen goods. This stark contrast raises questions about the fairness and equity of the legal system’s approach to first-time shoplifting offenses.

Impact on low-income individuals

The consequences of these fines can particularly affect people with limited financial means. The burden of repaying fines may lead to additional challenges, such as difficulty covering basic living expenses or fulfilling familial obligations. This cycle of financial strain can exacerbate the challenges that first-time offenders face.

Advocates argue that a more balanced and nuanced approach to punishment could better serve the interests of justice. Addressing the financial burden on individuals who commit low-value shoplifting offenses can help ensure that the punishment aligns with the severity of the crime.